About Me

My photo
Pursuing the 100 BEST courses in Canada, using SCOREGolf's Top100 lists as a guide. Completed the 2016 Top 100 (Oct 7, 2018 @ 26 yrs old), the 2018 Top 100 (Aug 2, 2024 @ 32 yrs old), the 2020 Top 100 (June 16, 2024 @ 32 yrs old), the 2022 Top 100 (May 17, 2024 @ 32 yrs old). I'm the only person living outside of the Toronto area to have played a Canadian top 100 list and was only the 2nd to ever complete such a list. 99/100 played on SCOREGolf 2024 list. 60/100 of America's 100 Greatest played. 384 total courses played. Continuing to chase top 100 contenders, and other greats around the world.

Thursday, 2 June 2022

Jasper Park Lodge - Supplement #1 (Eden)


Jasper Park Lodge was the first course I wrote about when creating this blog in 2012. Not only is it the single most influential golf course in my ongoing obsession with golf course architecture, but also among the most important projects in Canadian golf history.

It was the first of Canada's 'golden age elite' that I had the privilege of playing, which (obviously) resulted in a limited understanding of what I was seeing. At the time I didn't understand why JPL changed my perspective of golf course design; it just did.

I played the course as many times as possible while the junior rate was available to me, then set off to play anywhere and everywhere throughout my 20s. It wasn't until late 2020 (a few years after completing the entire top 100) that I revisited Jasper Park Lodge.

While I expect to have several supplementary posts for this course over my lifetime, I wanted to get this first one in ASAP as a way of recording my thoughts. From my time retracing steps on these sacred grounds, reading about the course's origins, and viewing maps from the 1920s, I've come to a few realizations that I don't believe have ever been documented. Most recently, I did not see any mention of the following ideas in Ian Andrew's book "In Every Genius There's a Little Madness" (a read that I highly recommend).

Unlike many American counterparts of his era, Stanley Thompson is not known for creating template holes - holes on different golf courses that clearly follow a recurring visual and/or strategic theme. Charles Blair Macdonald was the first to normalize this practice, which was carried forward by his associate Seth Raynor (and later, by his associate Charles Banks). Many of the Macdonald/Raynor templates are still frequently constructed today. Lesser architects will even emulate them unknowingly, due to their prevalence in the golf world.

Thompson was more inclined to craft 18 unique holes, as he and no others had seen before. He was a master at utilizing the terrain, allowing nature to shape his golf courses. Thompson simply identified the holes that were already there (and added some of the most artistic bunkering the world had ever seen). Though he was a proponent of variety within each golf course (par 3s of varying length, par 4s of varying challenge/opportunity, par 5s with varying risk/reward, etc.), he did not recreate holes on different golf courses. However different each creation is, each is uniquely and undeniably his. This is part of what makes playing a Thompson course for the first time particularly exciting.

While Thompson did not continuously recreate 'template' holes, he did unquestionably draw inspiration from the world's greatest existing golf courses at the time. In the 100+ years since Thompson began building golf courses, public opinion has evolved. Golfers are now more likely to identify a "short" par 3 (a wedge/short iron to a heavily contoured green with penal surrounds) or a "cape" par 4 (a mid-length hole doglegging softly to a green surrounded by hazards on 3 sides) given their popularity and prevalence. In the age of photography-guided architecture, both tend to (not surprisingly) be beautiful holes.

However, in the early 1900s St. Andrew's 11th hole (Eden) was considered to be the ideal par 3. A mid-length one-shotter to a green sloping sharply back to front, with a collection area at the rear of the green (leaving a dreadful 2nd shot if missing long off of the tee). The Eden hole, named after the River Eden which frames St. Andrews 11th, includes three bunkers: Hill (left flank), Strath (fronting pot bunker) and Cockleshell (large bunker short of the green). A 4th bunker (Eden) is often included on re-creations in place of the depression to the rear.

Old Course at St. Andrews 11th hole (source: Google Maps)

Though not as photogenic from the tee as it's modern counterparts, the Eden hole was so strategically strong that CB Macdonald adopted it as one of his template holes; nearly every Macdonald course includes a reinterpretation of this hole. In fact, it was so commonly created that there is fierce debate as to which Eden is the best (aside from the original, of course). The debated Edens are all in the USA, with the vast majority in the northeast.

Let me add one more to the conversation: the 12th hole at Jasper Park Lodge.

I believe I am the first person to identify this hole as an authentic adaptation of the Eden hole. It's not surprising that others before me have not made this connection because A) Thompson has never been known to have built template holes B) the most commonly used tee box on JPL is not an original tee, and substantially changes the angle of the tee shot (thereby, the perception of the hole) C) the Cockleshell bunker is rarely used in American renditions, thus altering the common perception of an Eden's appearance.

Ironically, the fact that JPL's Eden is so visually different from all (but 1) of the Edens in the USA is what makes it so good. In fact, it may be the single most authentic golden era re-creation of the hole in North America... accepting that it is a mirror-image, or reverse-Eden. The characteristics of the hole are unmistakable.

JPL #12 (source: Google Maps)

While much more apparent when walking the land, the satellite image clear shows the distinct Strath and Cockleshell bunkers (now to the left) and the Hill bunker to the right. As with all North American Eden holes, there is an Eden bunker to the rear in place of a deep swale. When you walk to the current tee, the Cockleshell bunker looks out of place... it's no wonder it was intended to be more in the golfer's line of sight.

There are several reasons why I have absolutely no doubt that Stanley Thompson intended for this to be his adaptation of the Eden.

1) Thompson had a huge appreciation for the links courses of the UK, and (though I'm yet able to confirm his travel logs) toured many while serving the Canadian Armed Forces during WWI.

2) Thompson greatly admired the National Golf Links of America, and viewed it as a modern masterpiece. The golf course was the origin of CB Macdonald's template holes - a collection of what he believed to be the best holes in the British Isles - which he would reuse on each golf course. Macdonald's Eden hole at NGLA, visually, is the most similar to the Eden hole at the Old Course (although the green lacks the severity needed to make it a standout hole). I can't possibly fathom Thompson creating a hole that so closely resembles TOC #11 and NGLA #13 without intent.

3) If there is anything Thompson was known for, it was his larger-than-life personality; his nickname 'The Toronto Terror' was earned. Those with knowledge of some famous Thompson tales (tree clearing at Capilano, bunker shaping on JPL #9 - Cleopatra, and strong-handing the CPR to expand his budget for Banff Springs) would expect nothing less than some one-upsmanship... even when it came to someone who Thompson revered as much as CB Macdonald. Given the dullness of the green at NGLA's Eden, as well as somewhat underwhelming bunkering, I believe Thompson wished to build his own 'ode to St. Andrews' with more authentic features.

NGLA's Eden #13 (my photo, 2018)

If one has any suspicions as to the resemblance between the current hole and the original Eden, consider the two images below:

Original JPL Course Map
(source: Ian Andrew's "In Every Genius There's a Little Madness)

Stanley Thompson's original rendering of the 12th hole bears a remarkable resemblance to NGLA's Eden hole. Note the original tee position, playing ACROSS the Cockleshell bunker. Also note that there was originally an Eden bunker marked to protect the back of the green (in lockstep with North American Edens). Whether or not the Eden bunker was originally built: I am doubtful, but don't know for certain.

Amended JPL blueprint - 1929
(source: Ian Andrew's "In Every Genius There's a Little Madness)

With the tug-of-war between Banff Springs and Jasper Park Lodge in the mid-late 1920s, Thompson was brought back shortly after completion of the course to add artistic flair and character to the originally simple looking JPL course (in an attempt to out-do Banff's dramatic features). Bunkers were re-carved with mounding added throughout the course, often to mimic the mountainous vistas. As visible in the above 1929 map, there is no Eden bunker behind the green, but rather a deep depression. I believe that Thompson's original plan for the hole was heavily influenced by the National Golf Links. An amendment was made shortly thereafter (removing the 4th bunker and adding character to others) to pay homage to the Eden at St. Andrews.

As seen on the earlier Google Maps satellite image, the rear Eden bunker has been added in accordance with the original course map. While I prefer the authentic 3-bunker configuration, the Eden bunker is an 8' deep show-stopper (below).

"Eden" bunker, off the back of the 11th hole (my photo, 2020)


Given the strong contouring of this green relative to the Eden at the NGLA, I believe the 1929 variation of Jasper Park Lodge's 12th not only was a (reverse) Eden... I'm confident it was the single most faithfully re-created North American Eden of the early 20th century.

Stanley Thompson's Eden (my photo, 2010)


While I wanted to make sure to publish this particular article ASAP, I have two others that I intend on writing in coming weeks regarding other holes at JPL. The first is an in-depth follow up to a brief writeup I did for SCOREGolf magazine in 2020 about the 'Cape' 14th hole. Given that I've already published my understanding of this hole as another out-of-character template variation, it was a less urgent blog entry than this one. Lastly, there is one other hole at JPL with strong Old Course/NGLA origins that I'm eager to dive into. I will leave my readers guessing as to which hole I may be referring to.


'Til next time, keep your stick on the ice!

The Golfing Canuck




Thursday, 17 January 2019

Canada's Top 100: COMPLETE

Well folks, 2018 was a year to remember!


I entered the season at 67/100, having played every top 100 west of Hamilton. Of the remaining 33, 28 were in Ontario, 1 in Quebec, 3 in Nova Scotia, with 1 pesky outlier in Newfoundland. This total was far more than I could have played in one or two trips (based on the high number and geographic dispersion of these remaining courses). Consequently, I approached the year with the intent of playing as many as possible, and returning in 2019 to finish off whatever I couldn't get to in 2018.

My first big trip targeted the Muskoka region, a golf rich area that I had yet to visit. While I've grown accustomed to 36 hole days, I knew I would need to ramp-up the intensity of this trip. Planned for mid-June, I knew the long days would allow me to tackle several 54 hole days on the tightly packed set of top 100 courses in the region. This is precisely what I did! Along with a few elusive rounds in the GTA that I was extremely fortunate to arrange (Goodwood, Magna, etc.), I finished the trip having added 19 new top 100 courses to my list in only an 8 day span.

The signature 14th at Oviinbyrd - the crown jewel of Muskoka golf

With a trip previously planned to NY, I decided to piggy-back a few days in Nova Scotia to make the pilgrimage to Cabot and Highlands Links. With flights booked, I made the bold decision to ferry to Newfoundland (a 7 hour overnight ferry) for a single day to play Humber Valley... when in Rome...

The wildly hectic itinerary of the NY/NS/NL trip took a toll on me, but I headed home at 90/100 (as well as 30/100 of America's greatest, having added NGLA, Friars Head, Winged Foot x2, and many others).

Par 4 17th on Canada's best course (seconds before a near albatross)

While still in New York I received a surprise invitation to play the Toronto Golf Club in roughly 2 week's time. This had been the most challenging golf course for me to access on my Canadian top 100 list. This was my opportunity!

I booked flights to return to the east within a few days of arriving home (on minimal rest, as previously mentioned). 10 courses remained. Of those, TGC and Rosedale were the anchor rounds, being the most difficult to arrange. Seven others were simply a matter of days/conditions. One would be a hurdle.

Google map the drive from Rideau View Golf Club to the Fairmont Le Manoir Richelieu if you want to know what I mean.

With the finish line in sight (and with a little help from the Yankees/Red Sox ALDS play-by-play), I got through my first 9 rounds. 99/100. Only Rosedale remained. The 10 hour drive from #99 Richelieu to #100 Rosedale is the furthest I have driven to golf on consecutive days. I reached Ottawa at roughly 1:00 am, and completely the journey back to Toronto the next morning.

Dramatic 1st tee (#10 for my round) at Le Manoir Richelieu
When the finish line came into sight earlier in 2018, I pondered where I'd like to end my great endeavor. The obvious answer was #1 Cabot Cliffs, though I soon came to realize that this wouldn't be possible (with how trip planning came together). With the 10 courses I had left going into my final trip, I decided Toronto GC or Rosedale would be fitting locations to complete the list.. should the golfing gods allow. My storybook ending fell perfectly into place.

A grim forecast kept many members from Rosedale on the day I was scheduled, yet the rain never fell. My threesome was one of only two on the course.

Years ago I would catch myself dreaming of how I would complete the top 100 - strolling down the 18th fairway to thunderous applause. Like a (soon-to-be) first time major champion with a 12 shot lead on the 72nd hole. OK... I might not have envision quite the reception that Tiger received when he closed out the 1997 Masters, but I thought it would be a highly celebrated occasion. Perhaps friends and family would be there to congratulate me on this rarest of accomplishments.

It was, in a way, poetically ironic that I completed my journey nearly in isolation, with only my two hosts commending my efforts. The solitude of the game (especially when golfing alone) is what initially got me hooked as a 13-year-old. 13 years later, on a mostly empty golf course, I became the second person to play all of Canada's 100 best golf courses.

The final stroke of my top 100

One monumental feat complete. Many more to come.


'Til next time, keep your stick on the ice!

The Golfing Canuck

Tuesday, 24 January 2017

Royal Colwood Golf Club

The Royal Colwood Golf Club is among western Canada's most noteworthy classic courses. It was the first solo design by legendary architect A.V. Macan, who later designed the likes of Shaughnessy, Marine Drive and nearby Victoria Golf Club. Americans are likely more familiar with the Cal Club of San Francisco, of which Macan provided the routing (and is credited with the original design). The loyal Canadian (actually born in Ireland) served his country in WWI , losing part of his leg in the Battle of Vimy Ridge. While he is most well known for his contributions to the world of golf, his service to his country should not be forgotten. Amazingly, Macan continued to play golf at a high level even after losing part of his left leg. But lets step back a few years...

Before volunteering for service in the 1st World War, Macan completed Royal Colwood. The old gem of a course is charming from start to finish. Its easy to see why so many people enjoy it so much here. Macan's clever routing is still evident, making use of the gently rolling terrain that covers most of the back 9.

Despite all of the great classic features of the course, it is not without fault. The most glaring are the bunkers, which (as of my last visit a few years ago) are in need of a restoration/renovation. This past summer I had the privilege of seeing the recent restoration work at Macan's nearby Victoria GC; if Royal Colwood had a similar bunker restoration, the course would be much more visually appealing and would play more true to the way I believe it was designed to play.

The first example of this is at the par 4 second hole. This beautiful 2-shot hole plays over the road that brings you into the club, and is guarded by bunkers down either side of the fairway. I believe these bunkers are supposed to prevent players from having a clear shot to the green, although they no longer present such a challenge.

Approaching the 2nd green.
The second green location is one of my favorite on the course, subtly built into the hillside. If you look closely, you can see the dramatic drop off the left side of the green, which is visually obstructed by the bunker to the left.

Holes 3 and 4 are flat, with greens guarded by a fronting stream. Many talk about them as though they are difficult holes, although I didn't find either to be overly challenging. The last of the flat holes is the par 5 5th, with a nice green complex. The round really gets going on the approach to the 6th hole. The uphill approach requires a carry over bunkers if you don't get your drive far down the fairway. The further your drive, the more the green opens up, and the easier the angle gets. Its a well designed hole which I think would benefit greatly from some bunker work.

Uphill approach to #6 after a mid-length drive
The short 7th is a pretty little downhill hole. The boomerang green is gentle, and generous in size, but guarded on all sides by hills and bunkers. The view is somewhat obstructed from the tee, but this is what you see:

The nice little 7th
Hole 8 can nearly be driven by longer hitters, but has one of the most well-guarded greens on the course. Its a really good hole as-is, but would benefit greater from some restored bunker faces on the green-side traps (see a recurring theme?). The front side ends on a strong par 4 with an uphill approach that takes you back close to the clubhouse.

The 10th is, in my opinion, the most bland hole on the course, offering no memorable characteristics. The large net protecting the course from the driving range on the right also takes away from the appeal of the 10th, although it is necessary to prevent fatalities from stray range balls.

While there is little elevation in play on the par 3 11th, the hillside behind frames the hole and sets the stage for the rest of the back 9. This hillside must be carried from the 12th tee, likely one of the most picturesque spots on the course (thanks to the majestically mature trees lining the hole).

Disorienting height of trees on 12th tee
#13 falls back down this hill, with an approach over water to a deceptive green. The 13th green is one of the most pictured areas of the course, although pictures never do justice to the severity of the green and intricacy of its contours. I was greatly surprised by how challenging it is.

Challenging 13th green (I'll try to capture it better when I return)
The short par 5 14th (under 500 yards) could be easily be written off by those fail to appreciate it's timeless charm. A solid drive will leave a straight-forward approach, but a shorter tee shot will leave an uphill shot with an obstructed view. The genius of the hole is in the layup, although modern equipment allows many to attack in 2, thereby preventing them from considering the aspects of the hole that Macan intended the golfer to consider. I quite enjoy the course's resistance to modernization/lengthening, even though it makes some golfers overlook the design of holes like #14.

2nd shot to the par 5 14th - modern equipment allows an easy attack, but consider the intended layup options!
At the cost of beating a dead horse, I must reiterate that gentle bunker restorations would correct this issue - the green-side bunkers on the 14th no longer present much of a threat, encouraging anyone in range to gun for the green in two. With stronger bunkers, the golfer would be forced to consider laying up, thus restoring the intended strategy of the hole. Mr. Mingay, please give this hole the same work you gave to #12 at Victoria GC!

From the furthest point on the course, the 15th starts the trek back to the clubhouse. Following this short par 3, the par 4 16th brings you back into one of the most beautifully wooded places on the course. Though quite short at 370 yds, I found the distances to be deceiving on this hole, likely due to the massive trees lining the fairway and surrounding the green. The setting makes you feel as small as an ant. In my opinion, one of the more underrated holes on the course!

Deceiving approach to the short 16th
Hole 17 makes great use of the land, tumbling down the hill to a generous green. A bunker roughly 40 yds short-right of the green is likely intended to obstruct the view of a golfer who bails out to the right off of the tee (to the more open side of the fairway), but no longer does so. A good hole if given a gentle face-lift.

The closing tee shot is one of the most memorable on the course, and is a mirror image of the famous 18th at Riviera. From a lower level, the tee shot must carry to a raised fairway running gently to the left (whereas Riviera's 18th bends right). Worth noting: Royal Colwood celebrated it's 100 year anniversary in 2013, shortly before I played, making it 13 years older than Riviera - perhaps George C. Thomas took inspiration from this hole? Having played both, I can't argue with the fact that the American rendition is superior. I found the approach to be flat and lacking interest, which is a slightly disappointing way to end a fun round.

Riviera-like tee shot on #18
Walking off of the 18th I reflected upon my overall impression of the course. Would I consider it among Canada's elite courses? No. As it sits, a really good layout? Of course. With gentle restoration, among the better courses in BC? I believe so. But I stress that it needs some work to get there. While some of the course's visual appeal has faded with time, so too has the utility of many of it's features. I wouldn't argue with anyone who thought playing corridors are a little bit too narrow in places, given the immense tree growth. However, I feel as though a few tight fairways are fair so long as the club is resistant to any notion of lengthening - which I believe it should be.

Having played all three of Macan's highly rated layouts in British Columbia, I've felt as though his courses have grown on me. With such experience I would offer this advice to anyone who may feel underwhelmed after playing a Macan course for the first time: try to play a second one; then play a third. Try to see more of his work. In doing so, pay close attention to how he incorporates the natural features of the land. As with other successful architects of the early 20th century, Macan created a lot of memorable holes without moving much earth. Many of those holes can be found at his first design.


'Til next time, keep your stick on the ice!

The Golfing Canuck

Sunday, 11 September 2016

SCOREGolf Top 100 - 2016

Since starting this blog a few years ago I have stuck with the SCOREGolf top 100 list from 2012. I considered switching to the 2014 list at the time of its release, but chose to pursue a fixed target rather than a moving one. In addition to pursuing a fixed goal, I was also persuaded by, what I perceived to be, a weak 2014 list with many inaccuracies. While no list is ever perfect, I wanted to chase the most accurate top 100 list.

The 2016 list is, in my opinion, the best top 100 list to date.

For this reason, I will be switching my blog to the 2016 list. It is not without fault, but no list ever will be. There are some deserving additions (Royal Mayfair, Tower Ranch, etc) since the 2012 list, and very few exclusions. With time, many courses have found a more deserving place on the list (Bear Mountain - Mountain down significantly to #72; meanwhile Victoria GC has crept up to #23).

An unfortunate exclusion in 2012, Tower Ranch climbs to #45 in 2016
Puzzlingly left off of consecutive lists, the classic Royal Mayfair is back at #59

Since pursuing the most accurate top 100 is my ultimate goal, it would seem ludicrous to use a list that doesn't include both Cabot courses. This has contributed to my decision to update the list, and also points to a need to update again in the future.Why? In a word: Sagebrush

While it seems strange to use a list without Cabot, it also seems unusual to exclude Sagebrush. With the recent ownership changes and zoning issues Sagebrush has not been open long enough to get the required number of rounds to get rated. This will surely change as soon as the course opens its doors again. I plan to update my list when Sagebrush reclaims it's place high on the list.

I expect Sagebrush to be back for 2018, but we will not see the Kananaskis courses back until at least 2020. After the devastating floods of 2013, restoration efforts began this summer with completion expected in 2018. One, if not both of the Kananaskis courses will almost certainly be back on the list shortly after reopening. Dundarave has fallen out of the top 100 for similar reasons - record snowfalls the winter before last killed much of the grass on the course. Like Kananaskis, expect Dundarave to sneak back into the top 100 in the future, when conditions recover.

Washed away in the 2013 floods, Kananaskis has an anticipated 2018 reopen

I do intend on solidifying a top 100 list as my fixed goal, but will continue to update my blog as new/restored courses find their way back into the top 100. Since I intend on completing the top 100 before a 2022 list is released, I will likely end up ultimately using the 2020. Until that time, I will use the most accurate list to date, which is the current (2016) list.

As I enter the 4th year of my bachelor's degree and prepare for national/licensing exams, my blog progress will likely slow. I plan to chip away at posts, but will not have significant writing time until the semester nears an end. Thank you for continued support and interest in my adventures. Stay posted for what's to come!


'Til next time, keep your stick on the ice!

The Golfing Canuck

Friday, 29 July 2016

Riviera & LACC

Although I promised to supplement my Pete Dye GC/Greenbrier post with Valhalla/Victoria National, I have decided to hold off on those courses until I am caught up on Canadian courses and focusing on American posts...

...AND because yours truly has recently completed one of the greatest days a golfer can have: a 36 hole day starting at LA Country Clubs North course, followed by Riviera Country Club. I'm still trying to convince myself that it happened to me, a kid from a city that sits under ice and snow for half of the year, and (fittingly) cares a lot more about hockey than all other sports combined.

The first round at LACC was all the more sweet, since I have had arrangements to play the course twice before, but was denied on both occasions very last-minute for reasons beyond my or anyone else's control. This time my fortunes were different!

Proof that I finally got through the glorious gates at LACC
To make a long story short, it was 100% worth the wait. What a course. What an experience!

As is often written about LACC, the course is built on very hilly terrain with barrancas running through many holes on the course (sometimes more than once on a hole). Having read much about the course, I had an idea what to expect.. I was still not expecting the course to be as hilly as it was!

Holes 3, 4, 6 and 8 are much hillier than pictures can capture. That being said, I'll try to show the severity of the 6th. This short par 4 is on my short list of the best par 4s I've ever played (every bit as good as #10 at Riviera). From the tee the green is not visible, but can be reached if you take an aggressive line down the right (over the small bunch of trees in the foreground).

Dramatic drop from the tee on the reachable 6th
The layup area over the hillside to the left is generous, but leaves a devilish approach to a very narrow green. Its simply one of the world's great short par 4s... my playing partners all agreed!

Almost every green on the course is fantastic. Multiple tiers on the 9th green come to mind immediately, as well as the reverse redan 11th, tricky 12th, and nervy 14th. The tiny par 3 15th could potentially play under 100 yds for the US Open if a front pin position is used, and I sure hope this is the case. The green is most similar to the 6th.. not severely sloping, but extremely shallow (depending on pin position). At 100 yds it is no pushover!

I also thought #17 was a terrific hole - a tough, long and narrow par 4 with plenty of bunkers and a barranca running down the right. The approach puts Gil Hanse's stunning bunkering on display.

17th green
One of very few weaker points on the course is the 18th. With the tees back for the US Open it will be a very long finisher, but has no real distinguishing features. I wouldn't say its a bad hole, but I felt as though it was an underwhelming conclusion to an outstanding round of golf.

There was hardly time to catch my breath as I grabbed a sandwich for the short drive over to Riviera. Speaking of lunch at LACC, the clubhouse was closed for renovations, but the halfway house is the among the best I've had the pleasure of stopping in at. I highly recommend the tuna salad sandwich with a cactus cooler.

The Riviera Country Club needs little introduction. It has been a fixture on the PGA Tour for decades, and has hosted a number of majors, although none since the 1995 PGA Championship. The course is always among the top courses in America, and at the time of my round was ranked #57 in the world.

I made it just in time to tee off, and was happy to stripe a drive from the famous elevated tee near the even more famous clubhouse. I visited the club a few months prior to watch the Northern Trust Open, but was still surprised by the depth of the bunker fronting the 1st green. The bunkering on the entire course is world class. There isn't a single hole on the course that doesn't have at least 1 jaw-dropping deep bunker.

The intimidating deep bunker short-left of the 2nd green
The entire property the course is built on is painfully flat, lacking natural features to work with. The only assistance offered by the land is the hillside on the north-west side of the course, and the barranca running through the south side of the land. The first 5 holes benefit from the hillside on the north side, playing up and down it 4 times.

The 6th is one of few holes on the course with no aid from nature, but Thomas' work here is spectacular. The small bunker in the middle of the green is as famous as the course itself. Having a temporary green on this hole was the biggest disappointment of the day. This must be the best example of Thomas making something from nothing.

Holes 7 and 8 bring the barranca into play, while 9 comes back to the north hillside. I was surprised how uninviting the left fairway is on the dual-fairway 8th; the right fairway seems more welcoming, and sets up a better angle for the approach. Either way, it is a really cool hole.

When dreams come true....
The 10th is as good as everyone says it is. Mesmerizing. It is hard to choose a target because there appears to be even less fairway than there actually is. In an attempt to hit it just past the green on the left side, I found the large left bunker short of the green. With the golfing gods smiling down upon me, I flushed the 60 yard bunker shot to 8 ft, and made one of the most memorable birdies I will ever have.

While the barranca running through the 11th isn't really in play, it can wreak havoc on the 12th and 13th holes. Both are awesome, long par 4s. The bunkers on the 14th are deeper than they look on TV, as is the fairway bunker on 15 (which I made the mistake of entering.. 1 shot penalty!). The 15th green doesn't get as much attention as it should; it is really good, and hard to read.

The 16th is one of the world's prettiest short par 3s. The most striking characteristic of this hole is that it is surrounded by trees not found on the rest of the course. It is like stepping into a bubble for a short while. SO cool. The bunkers here are also among Thomas' best, and the green is delightfully tiny.

Some of the best bunkering I've ever seen, at the par 3 16th
The 17th is a strong 5 which is almost unreachable. I say 'almost' only because I watched Rory hit a 310 yard second shot to 15 ft when I was here a few months ago to watch the PGA.. thats what it takes to hit the green in 2. The right greenside bunker is unimaginably deep. I almost couldn't see my playing partner who found the bunker. It is incredible architectural work on land that offers the architect nothing.

#18 is one of the best parts of the property for natural features. The famous uphill tee shot is not very intimidating if you trust your driver, but can be an automatic double bogey for those who don't.

World-renowned tee shot at #18
The trees to the right creep into play for the approach unless you really favor the left side of the fairway (which doesn't necessarily leave an easier approach). It truly is one of the great finishing holes in golf. A fitting conclusion to a dream day of golf!

Everyone always wants to know - which course is better, LACC or Riveria? Here's my quick take:

Natural landscape/quality of natural features - LACC > Riviera
Use of natural features/maximizing the land - Riviera > LACC
Playing conditions - LACC > Riviera (Riviera was far more green and visually appealing, but the kikuyu is a pain in the backside for anyone who isn't used to it.. it really does impact your shot selection)
Bunkering - Riviera > LACC ... although this is marginal and completely subjective.. both are absolutely awesome
Atmosphere - Riviera is world-class... but LACC is second to none.
1st hole/opening stretch - Riviera > LACC
18th hole/closing stretch - Riviera > LACC
Short par 4 - LACC 6th > Riviera 10th
Long par 3 - LACC 11th > Riviera 4th
Short par 3 - LACC 15th = Riviera 16th
Overall par 3s - Riviera > LACC
Short 5 - LACC 8 > Riviera 1
Long 5 - LACC 14 = Riviera 17
Green complexes - LACC > Riviera (With the exception of #6 at Riviera, WOW)

Take all of that as you may! If I had to choose which one to play again, I would choose to play them both. George C. Thomas is easily among my favorite architects.. What a day!


'Til next time, keep your stick on the ice!

The Golfing Canuck

Monday, 27 June 2016

Mid-June Getaway!

I've recently returned from a quick trip to West Virginia, Kentucky and Indiana. In my 3 full days there I did a loop starting/finishing in Cincinnati, in which I played the Pete Dye GC, the Old White TPC at The Greenbrier, Valhalla and Victoria National. It was a very busy couple of days (particularly the first day, when I played an early round at Pete Dye GC, drove 3 hours to Old White for an afternoon tee off, and later drove into the night to arrive in Lexington)!

This, along with trips to Scottsdale in January and LA/Palm Springs in February, has pointed out a huge flaw in my blogging: the heading "Playing Canada's Top 100 Golf Courses". When I started this blog a few years ago I was still quite early in my university career, and was very limited with travel. Consequently, the realm of possibility seemed quite narrow in the immediate future. I thought Canada's top 100 courses was an achievable goal, and set my sights on this near-sighted target.

I am still placing a large emphasis on the Canadian top 100 (for the purposes of this blog), but will be broadening this emphasis as I catch up on course write-ups. This seems only fair, as I have been making 2-3 golf trips in the USA for every trip I take in Canada. The posts in this blog don't reflect all of my recent travels, but I will keep with the current format for the time being so I can find a proper way to document my American adventures! For now, I will just provide a brief write-up on this last trip of mine, in which I played the #1 private and public courses in West Virginia, along with the #1 private courses in Kentucky and Indiana.

PETE DYE GC

Front entrance of the Pete Dye Golf Club. Bridgeport, WV
As the front entrance indicates, the Pete Dye GC is built on an old mine, and the course is covered with remnants of the old mine. Train cars, tee markers made of the old tracks, and even open mine shafts provide a reminder of the properties previous occupants.

Some of my favorite tee markers...very fitting!
In short, the Pete Dye GC is the best Dye course I have played at this point in my travels, rankings aside. There is a plaque at the bag drop that says "18 of the most exciting and memorable holes I have ever built on one course"-Dye, which gives you an indication of what is to come. My quick take is that holes 1-2, 7-17 are just that: some of Dye's most exciting and memorable. There truly are some stretches of world-class holes. I started on hole 10, but will start from #1 for ease of describing the course. #1 and #2 are good starting holes, the first being relatively gentle, and the second having more teeth. 3,4 and 6 were the most bland on the course, with the 5th being a very awkward and uninviting hole. This is certainly the worst stretch on the course. Hole 7 is where the fun really begins.

The beautiful downhill par 3 7th
The downhill 7th, and roller-coaster ride par 5 8th are the most dramatic holes on the course among those without water in play. I thought 9 was a good strong par 4 which plays well as an 18th (as I played it). #10 is the most photographed hole, and rightly so!

Severely sloped par 4 10th
The drive and approach are obviously quite intimidating, but much more forgiving than you might think. At around 300 yards, the 12th is one of my favorite holes on the course. The green is out of sight from the tee, but there is enough room around the green to allow an aggressive play from the tee. The fairway is wide and encourages a layup, but a huge bunker on the left side of the hole obstructs the view to the green from a poorly positioned tee shot. The hole is both beautiful, and strategically interesting!

From right of the fairway on the awesome short 12th
While I really liked the 13th and 16th, and had no issue with 14 and 15, I'll skip ahead for now. The closing stretch is brutally difficult, but I really enjoyed 16 and 17, a long 3 and shorter 4. The challenge of 17 is the approach; the green is one of the toughest I've ever played. The green has a number of humps and ridges, and falls off on almost all sides. As I can attest to, the green is receptive and playable.. but I wouldn't want to put myself out of position!

The WILD 17th green
The closing hole is really unfortunate. It is far too difficult, bordering on unfair. The hole demands a long, straight drive over water, which will leave a mid-length, blind approach to a narrow green with bunkers on both sides, and water close to the left edge of the green. The hole is gorgeous... but almost unplayable. It was my least favorite on an otherwise incredible course.

After finishing I grabbed a quick lunch and drove 3 hours south to The Greenbrier, where I had an afternoon tee time at the Old White TPC. My first Macdonald/Raynor course!

Old White TPC

Simly put, it was love at first sight.

Within 2 weeks of visiting, the course was flooded, causing a cancellation of the PGA Tour's upcoming Greenbrier Classic. Devastating! Fortunately I had ideal conditions, and an amazing experience!

The first 2 holes are refreshingly simple par 4s with nice green complexes, leading you to the biarritz 3rd. My first authentic biarritz! Laying eyes on the 3rd was one of my favorite golf experiences in recent memory, it is an absolute stunner!

Biarritz from the tee

The biarritz from just off the back of the green looking back
Having read plenty about Raynor's template holes, I knew exactly what to expect from this gem... but seeing this hole in person was so much better than anything you can read. The green is massively long, it really is like 2 full greens. I can forever say that I birdied my first biarritz with a strong back pin. What a day!

The approach to the 4th may be the most bland on the front side, but whatever it lacks, the approach to #5 makes up for. Huge cone-line mounds obstruct the view of the left side of the green, which is actually much larger than it appears.

The fascinating par 4 5th, one of my favorites
#6 is the toughest hole on the course, while #7 is a birdie chance (a really aesthetically pleasing one at that!). The 8th was my first ever authentic Macdonald/Raynor redan, which also has mounds similar to the 5th.

Redan 8th
So much has been said about the original redans, I don't know what more I can add. All I can say is that this is a really, really good redan.. and that the green was far deeper than I imagined it would be. It is a generous hole if you hit a solid shot. I absolutely loved it.

The punchbowl 9th and principal's nose 10th are some of the prettiest holes on a course full of gorgeous holes. Both are birdie chances, particularly the 9th. #11's main defense is length, and has softer bunkering than most holes on the course.

The 'long' par 5 12th is breathtaking, and strategically fantastic. The green can be reached in 2, but takes a perfect drive, and precise 200+ yard second shot. As a 3 shot hole, it is no bargain either. The cross-bunkers and creek demand a careful layup.

The second shot on the par 5 12th.. Go for it or lay back?
The 'alps' 13th is a very beautiful hole, but I found that the mound fronting the right of the green was unnecessary, as the doglog right has heavy tree growth to the right. As such, it is almost impossible to hit a drive that will cause the small mountain to obstruct the view of the green. It is, nonetheless, a really cool hole.

A really beautiful 14th guides you to the 'eden' 15th. This rendition of the eden is extremely pretty, but I was slightly disappointed that the slope of the green wasn't greater. By no means a bad hole, however.

The 'cape' 16th wasn't a bad hole, but it may have been my least favorite on the back 9. In retrospect, I think this may have been because I found it difficult to identify a reference point/target line from the tee. In other words, I couldn't tell how aggressive I was actually playing. I feel like this takes away from the purpose (risk/reward) of a cape hole.

I loved #17, a long par 5. The classic design includes a series of cross bunkers which must be navigated on a lay-up. None of my pictures captured the feel you have standing there in person. It wasn't until I got up to the green that I realized the plateau-like drop off that lies beyond the green.

Back edge of the 17th green
The slope is only about 2 ft high, but is steep enough to prevent a 'bump-and-run' into the hill, and likely deter the use of a putter. With a green running away, it is a really tough chip. I absolutely loved #17, tee to green.

As many know, the Old White TPC is one of few courses that ends on a par 3. I didn't get to play it from normal tees (due to tournament preparation), so I will not further comment. It is easy to find pictures of the green, which is the main defense, with a large slope bisecting the green.

Of the 4 courses I played on this quick trip, Old White certainly is not the best course, but it very well could have been my favorite. It truly is a classic gem. Raynor's work (the amount of Macdonald's original design that still exists is up for debate) is just incredible. Without exaggeration, there are 9 signature holes. Of the remaining holes, I felt as though 6 were really good, and 3 were okay. If not for the hefty price tag, I would happily play here every day and never get tired of it... isn't that what actually makes a course great? I sure think so.

I intended on including all 4 of the courses from my trip in this post, but I have already written a lot more than I expected I would. Therefore, I am going to end here, and write a supplemental post for the other 2 courses I played: Valhalla and Victoria National. Stay posted for what's to come!


'Til next time, keep your stick on the ice!

The Golfing Canuck

Monday, 20 June 2016

Predator Ridge - Ridge


When I made my first trip to Kelowna/Vernon to play the Predator course, the Ridge course had only just opened to members for limited 'preview' play. It was not yet available to the public. After my first of back-to-back rounds on Predator, I brushed shoulders with Jarome Iginla (hockey royalty in western Canada, and a resident at Predator Ridge.. as are many NHL players). He was just coming off of the 18th green of the Ridge, so I asked him what he thought of it. He simply grinned and said "oh.. better than Predator..". At the time Predator was ranked #59 in Canada, so I knew the Ridge had to be really good.

An aside; if you want some interesting trivia knowledge, look up Jarome Iginla's full name.

Predator Ridge originally consisted of 3 distinct 9s designed by Les Furber. The Redtail/Osprey combo made the famous 18 that hosted multiple skins games, and the Peregrine was the extra 9. After years of this arrangement, Doug Carrick was brought in to make Predator Ridge a 36- hole facility. He added a number of new holes, while altering many from the original Peregrine 9 to create the new Ridge course. As a big fan of Carrick's courses, I was excited to see how this would compare to Furber's Predator course (which I enjoyed but felt was slightly overrated)

I eagerly awaited a chance to return to see the Ridge course for myself, and got that chance a few years later while living near Vancouver. I had beautiful weather, but was disappointed to find out the greens had been aerated just days before. I happily accepted my discounted green fee and headed to the first tee.

With the exception of the hole #1, the first 7 holes play downhill. There is slight elevation gain through the middle of the course, and the closing stretch is almost completely flat.

The start and finish of the Ridge use the original Peregrine holes, with the middle of the round being all newly designed. I didn't play Peregrine before the renovation, but can imagine that it would've played much like the other original 9s. The first hole was not significantly reshaped, but had new bunkers to blend with Carrick's style. A nice way to start the round.

Short, uphill approach to the 1st, with Carrick's new bunkers
As you reach the second tee, the round starts to get really interesting. The original 27 at Predator Ridge was quite hilly, but had very few extreme elevation changes. I don't know exact numbers, but the tee shot on #2 must drop 100 ft. The fairway is more forgiving than one might expect, but finding the left side will obstruct your view on the approach.. which also drops severely.

2nd tee
Approach at the 2nd
If you look really closely, you can see my ball next to the hole, above. As my dad would say, "every now and then even a blind squirrel finds a nut". The 3rd plays much like the 1st: a slight dogleg right with a gentle climb. The slopes are a bit stronger than at #1, so it is quite fitting that hole 3 has no bunkers.

Hole 4 also bends to the right, but with an uphill tee shot and downhill approach. The green, perched high above a hill looks like its hanging off the edge of the earth. Picture an infinity pool. The 5th is often considered the post-card hole on the course, so why not throw my picture into the mix as well. The long par 3 obviously has a huge drop, with a great rugged backdrop. I'm looking forward to getting out to Muskoka, I imagine it looks much the same.

The signature par 3 5th
You can see how disappointing it was to have freshly punched greens, but its still easy to see how exciting and dramatic the layout of the course is. The steepest drop on the course is likely at the 6th. a 400 yd, drive-able par 4. Some love it, some hate it. I was on the 'love' end of the spectrum, although it wasn't my favorite hole on the course.

A drop from the tee at the par 5 7th gives you a chance to attack the hole in 2, but the elevated green is well guarded. Its followed by a long 3 with inviting mounding right of the green.

The short par 5 9th is possibly the most unique hole on the course. The fairway meanders through a number of huge rock outcroppings.

The rugged par 5 9th
A good drive will give you the green light on the second shot, but a poor drive will make you work around the most prominent outcropping which cuts into the fairway from the left. A good birdie opportunity.

The 10th is one of few uphill holes on the course, and is a great one at that. Despite being a short hole, the green is out of reach. The golfer must choose how aggressive they'd like to be.

Uphill 10th, how aggressive do you want to be?
If you lay back to the start of the fairway (150 yds) the green will be mostly out of sight. There is a higher plateau just beyond the first right-hand bunker, which leaves a gentle wedge approach. This is a gorgeous little hole which should be a sure-par if you keep a level-head, but can bite you if you get wreckless.

A long-ish par 5, the 11th is less exciting, and has a narrow green as its main defense. Its very receptive to short approaches, but doesn't welcome seconds shots.

Something about the 12th was extremely appealing to me. The par 3 has a bit of a punchbowl feel with the surrounding rocky landscape, although it is not a true punchbowl green. This corner of the course is evening more beautiful than my picture shows... but here's a look.

Really cool 12th
The 13th and 14th have similar appearances, both playing through a narrow corridor with rocky mountainsides on either side. The first being a par 5 with a gentle bend right, the second being a par 4 with a gentle bend left. Both are good holes, but neither are signature holes.

By the 15th you've reached the edge of the course where Carrick's new holes meet up with Furber's previous holes. There is noticeable contrast in styles, which is obvious with the forced carries over water on 15-17. Much like #1, #15 is essentially a Furber hole with a Carrick bunker. Not my favorite par 3, especially considering how memorable the others are.

Of the converted Peregrine holes, 16 is by far the best. Playing 290-330 downhill, it is short enough to entice some to go for it. If you heard 295 yds, and saw this from the tee, would you go for it?

The inviting view from the tee on the short par 4 16th
The doesn't seem to be much standing between you and a sure birdie. However, if you take a minute to look at what lies ahead you'd be more inclined to lay back and set up a nice full wedge on the approach. This is what you see as you descend to the landing area...

16th green from 100 yds out
Not as welcoming as you would've first thought? Its a very fair hole which yields birdies... but you must play smart and plan your attack! Carrick changed the hazard lines on this hole, and added 2 new bunkers, but the overall strategy is much like it previously was. Of the Furber holes, this one is not only the best, but also blends with all of Carrick's new holes the best. One of my favorites.

The 17th is a 'tough-as-nails' long par 4. The "cape" template would accurately apply to this hole, as it entices golfers to bite off as much as they can chew. The bunkers are a conservative target, leaving a long approach. Most can carry the water just left of the bunkers (probably 200 or so), but the required carry gets out of reach quickly if you miss left!

The 'cape' par 4 17th
The approach is also no bargain. While Carrick did as much as he could to blend many old holes like this with his new ones, the marshy feel of 15 and 17 just don't fit the rest of the course (the marshy area reaches over to #16, but the 16th isn't dominated by it). The 17th isn't a bad hole, but it's differing feel disrupts the continuity of the round. In my mind, this hole pulls the Ridge course down a few spots in the rankings.

I think the 18th is a really good closing hole. It is by no means the signature hole on the course; it is just a good hole. It is easy to put the ball in play off of the tee, but a strong drive must be hit to allow an reasonable second shot. As you can see below, this is because the uphill approach is not very inviting to long, running shots. You definitely want to be hitting a shot iron into this green.

The final approach
I like how this hole sets up for tournament play. If you build a substantial lead, you can easily lay back off the tee, play conservatively with the second and try to get up and in for par. If you have a narrow lead, you have to hit strong shots; timid play will likely ensue in a bogey+. Similarly, if you are a shot or 2 behind, birdies can certainly be made with bold play. Its not a "death or glory" hole (which I rarely feel suit an 18th). If Carrick's other great BC course Greywolf had this finishing hole, it would rank 5 places higher... but that's just the humble opinion of a washed up competitive golfer (at 24, already reflecting on my 'glory days')

Although The Ridge and Greywolf are quite different courses, it seems only logical to compare Carrick's two best courses in western Canada. I feel as though Greywolf has more great holes, but also more weak holes. Even 1 or 2 ghastly ones. I don't think the Ridge has any terrible holes. Its weakness is the lack of continuity you feel as you play the converted Furber holes. Ironically, I felt as though the Ridge had less of a 'resort course' feel than Greywolf (ironic because of how noteworthy the Predator Ridge Resort is). I also found course conditions better at The Ridge. I must say, however, that I prefer the simple and elegant bunker styling at Greywolf. If I had to pick one of the two courses to play regularly, I would choose The Ridge. For that reason I give it the nod.

A friend from overseas recently told me he had limited time to visit Kelowna, and asked if I recommended The Predator course or Ridge course. I should, therefore, include a brief comparison of the 2 courses at Predator Ridge (although my post on the Predator course is still pending). Predator has stronger contouring around many of the greens, resulting in harsher penalties for poor approaches. I also found Predator to have more blind shots. The elevation changes and vistas are far more dramatic on The Ridge. The Ridge is not easy, but I found it to be more fair (rewarding good shots, and punishing....but not destroying... bad shots). Both are a lot of fun and worth playing. The Ridge is noticeably better in my mind.

As I also mentioned in my Greywolf post, I am also looking forward to returning to The Ridge course. I want to see the course with smooth greens, and see if my opinion of the 'feel' of the course has changed. Similarly to Greywolf, if you are planning a trip to Predator Ridge, let me know... I just might join you!


'Til next time, keep your stick on the ice!

The Golfing Canuck